1. Identify the system boundary and owners
- Inventory: applications, databases, files, scheduled tasks, interfaces, reports and external services involved in one process.
- Owners: business approver, users who know exceptions, technical support and account or licence holders.
- Access: source code, configuration, documentation, authorized test data and vendor constraints.
- Reason for change: a concrete operational problem or new requirement, with examples.
Evidence before proceeding: a system map and named contacts. “Replace the old software” is not yet an implementable scope.
2. Compare retaining, rehosting, integrating and replacing
Record at least the realistic options for the identified problem. Retaining means improving what already works. Rehosting changes its operating environment. Integration connects a defined boundary. Replacement changes selected behaviour or the whole application. Each has different compatibility, support and transition implications.
Evidence before proceeding: the requirement addressed, work retained, constraints, operating costs and reason for the selected first stage. Include an existing product if it may meet the need. A rewrite should earn its scope rather than be the default.
3. Capture rules and acceptance examples
- Trace a normal transaction, a correction and an exception with staff.
- Write down calculations, approvals, state changes and who may perform them.
- Identify the reports and totals the business relies on.
- Mark behaviour that must remain and changes that an owner explicitly approves.
Evidence before proceeding: representative inputs and expected outputs, with a named reviewer. A screenshot or list of database tables cannot explain every business rule.
4. Review data and access separately
Identify authoritative datasets, identifiers, relationships, history, attachments and known quality problems. Define who may view, change, approve or export information. If data moves, record mappings, rejected records and source-to-target checks.
Evidence before proceeding: an agreed data scope, role/action matrix and reconciliation criteria. Retaining a database does not automatically preserve every interface rule; moving it does not automatically create new permissions.
For Access, Microsoft describes a server-backend option that retains the desktop interface. Review that architecture on its actual merits rather than treating all Access systems alike.
5. Test dependencies and complete workflows
Staff should test complete tasks, not only individual screens. Include permission failures, invalid data, repeated requests, report calculations and unavailable connected services where applicable. Assess printers, local files, offline work or other desktop dependencies before assuming a browser will replace them.
Evidence before proceeding: recorded results against the agreed examples, unresolved exceptions and an explicit acceptance decision. A successful demonstration is not evidence for every report or integration.
6. Authorize cutover and recovery
- Name the release approver and the conditions that must be satisfied.
- Agree who may write to each old or new dataset during transition.
- Specify backups and the restore test needed before release.
- Define the final data checks and the point at which users switch.
- Document rollback triggers and how to handle records entered after the switch.
Evidence before proceeding: a reviewed release/recovery sequence and operational contacts. A parallel run is useful only when write ownership and reconciliation are controlled.
7. Confirm ownership and ongoing operations
List account ownership, licences, source/data handover, staff guidance, monitoring, updates, backups and support coverage. If Django is selected, review the deployment guidance for the implemented version as part of the production checklist. A framework or hosting provider does not remove the application owner’s operating responsibilities.
Illustrative example: an owner may approve replacing a manual approval queue while retaining a reporting tool. The decision record names the retained report, its data owner and the check proving the new queue does not change its totals. That is a bounded stage, not evidence that a full system conversion has been completed.
Use the modernization service for a broader system review. The workflow guide helps define the initial task, while the staged desktop replacement guide explains the implementation sequence once a web application is justified.



Comments
Leave a comment
Comments are reviewed before publishing.